While visiting Putinbay, we hope you stay at The Put-in-Bay Condos but due to our newness and location on the water, we are generally full far in advance. Put in Bay offers a variety of other lodging choices while you're vacationing on the Lake Erie Islands. Listed below are some recommended lodging alternatives if we are full or you just need another home for 8-16 people. Whatever your lodging needs, we are sure you'll be happy at one of the following PutInBay lodging alternatives. SEE YOU AT THE BAY ... Put in Bay Ohio.